Serious Lincoln fans may have heard a reference to the “alley by the journal office” but not know about it. Abraham Lincoln was known to be a sportsman for most of his life in an age when organized sports were hard to find. As a young man, Lincoln was a wrestler with extraordinary strength who was inducted into the National Wrestling Hall of Fame.
He was known to roll “Ten Pins” (bowling) [1], play Billiards (not Pool) [2], and Chess [3] but admitted that he never excelled at any of them. Mr. Lincoln engaged in these games for exercise and amusement, both physically and mentally. He routinely regaled those present with jokes, western anecdotes, and stories during play, which made him popular with opponents and teammates alike.
 |
| This is Abraham Lincoln's handball. It was found in a dresser drawer when Lincoln's Springfield house was being restored in the 1950s. Today the handball is in the Smithsonian in Washington, D.C. |
In the years before Lincoln was elected president, he was a successful Springfield lawyer. He often played handball in an alley by the Illinois State Journal newspaper office to ease his stress. The paper occupied a three-story building at 116 N. Sixth Street. The building next door immediately south was a three-story building that housed a store operated by John Carmody. The next building south was known as the Logan Building, owned by Judge Stephen T. Logan.
The large vacant lot between these two buildings was the site of the storied impromptu handball court used by lawyer Lincoln and his friends. The brick walls of the Carmody store and Logan building formed the front and back walls of the handball court, and the other two sides were enclosed by wood fences standing 6 to 8 feet high. The fences also had wooden bench seats for visitors watching the matches or for players waiting their turn to take on the winner.
The term handball didn’t exist in Lincoln’s day. Lincoln and his contemporaries called the game 'FIVES.' When Mr. Lincoln went into town, he frequently joined the boys to play handball. In the Springfield version, players choose sides to square off against one another. The game was begun by one of the boys bouncing the ball against the wall of the Logan building. As it bounced back, and opponent struck it in the same manner so that the ball kept going back and forth against the wall until someone missed the rebound. ‘Old Abe’ was often the winner, for his long arms and long legs were perfect for reaching and returning the ball from any angle his adversary could send it. The game required two, four, or six players, spread equally on each side. The three players who lost paid 10¢ ($3.25 today) each, making the winnings 30¢ a game. So as you can imagine, the games got pretty serious.
Court clerk Thomas W.S. Kidd spoke of Mr. Lincoln’s love of the game: “In 1859, Zimri A. Enos, Esq., Hon. Chas. A. Keyes, E. L. Baker, Esq., then editor of the Journal, William A. Turney, Esq., Clerk of the Supreme Court, and several others, in connection with Mr. Lincoln, had the fives 'court (alley),' then an open one, lying between what was known as the United States Court Building, on the northeast corner of the public square, and the building owned by a friend, Mr. John Carmody, on the alley north of it, on Sixth street, enclosed with a high board fence, leaving a dead wall at either end. In this ‘alley’ could be found Mr. Lincoln, with the gentlemen named and others, as vigorously engaged in the sport as though life depended upon it. He would play until nearly exhausted and then take a seat on the rough board benches arranged along the sides for the accommodation of friends and the tired players.”
In May of 1860, the most noteworthy game of 'fives' in our country’s history took place on this court. The Republican National Convention, held in a wood frame building known as the “Wigwam,” had kicked off in nearby Chicago on May 16th. The Whig party had imploded, the Free Soilers were migrating, and the anti-Catholic populists from the Know-Nothing party were flocking to the Republican Party with its anti-slavery message. Even though this promised to be a raucous convention, the eventual GOP nominee, “Abraham Lincoln,” decided to stay home as presidential candidates did not attend their National Convention.
Most Lincoln scholars agree that Lincoln played handball all three days of the convention (May 16-18) to relieve stress while waiting for news to arrive by telegraph at the Illinois State Journal newspaper offices. On the last day of the GOP convention, Friday, May 18, 1865, Lincoln rose bright and early and headed downtown (1/2 mile from home to office). Although nervous and anxious, Lincoln greeted neighbors and friends on the streets and on the square around the Illinois Capitol Building.
At 8:30 am, Lincoln nervously visited the second-floor office of lawyer James C. Conkling located at 119 S. Fifth Street. Mr. Conkling had just returned from Chicago, and Lincoln was anxious to hear any news from the convention. Conkling told Lincoln to relax, assuring him that he was sure to be nominated that day. Lincoln, however, was not so confident and told Conkling, “Well, Conkling, I guess I’ll go back to my office and practice law.” But here is where the narrative takes a mysterious turn.
Lincoln did not arrive back at his law office until just before 10 a.m. We know this from accounts of the many well-wishers, friends, and supporters who were waiting for the arrival of their candidate on the corner of Sixth and Adams on the square. Shortly after 10 o'clock, Edward L Baker, one of the editors of the Illinois State Journal, appeared at the office of Lincoln and Herndon with two bulletins in his hand. The first one announcing that the delegates were filing back into the Wigwam; the second, that the names of the candidates for president had been presented to the chairman of the convention.
The initial news was not good. When voting for the nomination began, William H. Seward led on the first ballot with 173 1/2 votes. Lincoln was a distant second tallying 102 votes. There were 465 delegates at the convention, making 233 votes necessary for the nomination. Simon Cameron received 50, Salmon P. Chase got 49, and Edwin Bates had 48. Witnesses claimed that, upon hearing the news, Mr. Lincoln threw himself upon a horsehair couch in the office without expressing any opinion on the news. By all accounts, Lincoln was very guarded in all of his statements that morning.
After a few minutes, Lincoln arose from the chair and said: “The dispatches appear to be coming to the Journal office… Let us go over there.” When the Lincoln entourage arrived at the foot of the stairway leading to the telegraph office on the north side of the public square, Lincoln said: “Let’s go up; it must be about time for the second ballot.” The results of the second ballot were coming across the ticker tape as Lincoln entered the room. The telegraph operator handed the news to Mr. Lincoln. Most of the Pennsylvania delegation jumped over to Lincoln on the second ballot, putting him in a near-tie with Seward (184 for Seward and 181 for Lincoln). Although silent, witnesses remember a look of satisfaction appearing on Lincoln’s face.
News soon arrived that many additional delegates switched to Lincoln on the third ballot, and he won the party’s nomination. Lincoln was nominated and would be elected the nation’s 16th president. He appointed Seward Secretary of State, Cameron Secretary of War, Chase Secretary of the Treasury, and Bates Attorney General.
But where was Lincoln from 8:30 am to 10 am? His longtime friend and bodyguard Ward Hill Lamon was the first to say that Lincoln was playing handball during that period. Henry Wirt Butler confirmed that he was engaged in a game with the candidate at Mr. Lincoln’s request while awaiting news from the convention. When young Mr. Butler was born, Lincoln was a practicing attorney in Springfield, living at the home of Mr. Butler’s parents. He had just finished reading the Life of William Wirt and suggested that the baby be named after the former U.S. Attorney General. When the boy whom Lincoln had named grew to be a young man, he became a favorite of the Great Emancipator’s and read law for some time in his office. It should be noted that Wirt was barely 20 years old, and Lincoln was 51 at the time of the game.
Lincoln’s friend, Dr. Preston H Bailhache, recalled a game of 'fives' played on a court built by Patrick Stanley in an alley at the rear of his grocery in the Second Ward. “I have sat and laughed many happy hours away watching a game of 'fives' between Lincoln on one side and Hon. Chas. A. Keyes on the other. Mr. Keyes is quite a short man, but muscular, wiry, and active as a cat, while his now more distinguished antagonist, as all now know, was tall and a little awkward, but which with much practice and skill in the movement of the ball, together with his good judgment, gave him the greatest advantage. In a very hotly contested game, when both sides were ‘up a stump’ — a term used by the players to indicate an even game — and while the contestants were vigorously watching every movement, Mr. Lincoln and Mr. Turney collided with such force that it came very near preventing his nomination to the Presidency, and giving Springfield a sensation by his death and burial. Both were badly hurt, but not so badly as to discourage either from being found in the ‘alley’ the next day.”
Another eyewitness was the unofficial gatekeeper of the 'Fives' Court, William Donnelly, a nephew of John Carmody. Years later, Donnelly offered this account to a reporter, “I worked in the Carmody store and usually had charge of the ball court. I smoothed the wall and leveled the ground. I made the balls. Old stockings were rolled out and wound into balls, and covered with buckskin. Mr. Lincoln was not a good player. He learned the game when he was too old. But he liked to play and did tolerably well. I remember when he was nominated as though it were yesterday. It was the last day of the convention, and he was plainly nervous and restless.”
Donnelly continued: “He played 'fives' a good deal during every day of the convention, evidently to relieve the over-strained mind. I was standing down in front of the Carmody store when Edward L. Baker, Charlie Zane (Judge), and one or two others brought word from the telegraph office that he was nominated. It was the bulletin showing the result of the third and last ballot. I naturally followed the crowd upstairs to the editorial room on the second floor. The stairway was in the alley outside the building. The telegram was read and then handed to Mr. Lincoln, who read it out aloud again. After a lot of handshaking, we returned to the street below. Mr. Lincoln appeared anxious to getaway. When he came to the entrance of the ball court, the players gathered around, congratulated him, and pledged him their support.”
The account continued: “He thanked them, looked at the telegram he had in his hand, and said: there’s a little woman over on Eighth Street that will be glad to hear the news; if you’ll excuse me, I’ll go and tell her. He then left for home. I can see him now as he went away. He leaned forward and walked mighty fast. The boy that went with him had to run almost to keep up with him. Mr. Lincoln never came back to the court or played handball after the day he was nominated. I did not vote for Mr. Lincoln in 1860. There were only three Irishmen who did. They were called Irish Republicans and were regarded as curiosities.”
John Carmody recalled another 'fives' game: “An incident occurred during one of those games, which I have retained clearly in my memory. I had a nephew named Patrick Johnson, who was very expert in the game. He struck the ball in such a manner that it hit Mr. Lincoln in the ear. I ran to sympathize with him and asked if he was hurt. He said he was not, and as he said it, he reached both of his hands toward the sky. Straining my neck to look up into his face, for he was several inches taller than I was, I said to him, ‘Lincoln, if you are going to heaven, take us both.’”
For years a myth circulated that Abraham Lincoln was playing 'fives' when he was notified that he had received the nomination for President. Obviously, that legend must be filed alongside the myth that Lincoln wrote the Gettysburg Address on the back of an envelope on the train ride to Gettysburg. Neither story is wholly true, but there is a grain of truth in each. Lincoln was playing 'fives' when the delegates in Chicago were voting, and he edited the Gettysburg Address on the train.
Historians confirm that Abraham Lincoln never returned to that handball court after that day. Years later, President Lincoln spoke about his athletic prowess on the night of his reelection as President in 1864: “For such an awkward fellow, I am pretty sure-footed. It used to take a pretty dextrous man to throw me.”
In October of 2004, the Smithsonian Institution displayed Abraham Lincoln’s handball as part of their exhibit “Sports: Breaking Records, Breaking Barriers.” It’s small (about the size of a tennis ball), dirty and well worn and really, really old. The ball has “No. 2” stamped on the side, but it is unclear if the stamp was on the ball when Lincoln handled it or if it was stamped on the side for reference years later. It came from the Lincoln Home in Springfield, where Lincoln lived from 1844 until 1861.
The ball was found in a dresser drawer when Lincoln's Springfield house was being restored in the 1950s. Smithsonian officials say the descendants of one of the men who played 'fives' with Lincoln donated it to the Lincoln Home. A contemporary newspaper article verified that the ball was indeed one of those used by Lincoln to play 'fives' in the alley.
There is one footnote about that handball you won’t find in the Smithsonian’s official literature. On May 18, 1860, when Lincoln was having a friendly neighborhood game of “fives” to calm his nerves, just a few blocks from the Wigwam, on the second night of the convention, the McVicker’s Theatre just a few short blocks away was opening "Our American Cousin" — the play Lincoln would be watching at Ford’s Theater his last night on Earth.
 |
| McVicker’s Theatre, Madison Street, West of State Street, Chicago, Illinois. (1857-1871) |
Although Assassin John Wilkes Booth was not in the production, he would appear at the McVicker’s four times in different productions between 1862 and 1863 while Mr. Lincoln was in the White House. Ironically, the McVicker's Theatre was the first place where actor Harry Hawk began theater work as a call boy or stagehand. Hawk was the actor on stage alone when Lincoln was shot and likely uttered the last words Mr. Lincoln ever heard. Who knew a well-worn piece of leather sports equipment could have so many connections?
Compiled by Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D.
[1] Abraham Lincoln was the first prominent American to spend time playing "ten pins." As German immigrants settled in America, bowling became a major part of their festivals and picnic gatherings. Chicago and New York were the first cities where the sport took root, and at that point, it was primarily an outdoor sport. The first indoor wooden lanes were built in the 1840s in Manhattan, and the sport soon became a fad in New York.
[2] One day in October of 1858, Lincoln met Frederick L. Fake by chance at the Hardy House at First and Wright Streets in La Salle, Illinois, while detained a few hours for tile lack of transportation. Three games of billiards were played to the keen amusement of the large crowd which soon gathered. Lincoln proposed the game and refused Fake's offer of a spot (i.e., handicap) of "forty points in the hundred," Lincoln divested himself of coat, waist-coat, collar, and necktie, rolling his shirt sleeves to shoulders. When shooting, he very carefully squared himself. The game was played on a billiards table (larger than a "pool" table with no pockets). Lincoln talked and told stories, perhaps several of them, much to the delight of the large crowd in the little room as he played. Fake apparently won the first game. Because Lincoln refused the offer of a 50 point spot (in a game to 100) for the second game, saying he had not played his best game, etc., they divided the expense at the finish. Much story-telling went on by Lincoln, particularly of what he did not know of billiards, making everybody happy with a performance long to be remembered.
What a marvelous account! It shows Lincoln proposing the game, rejecting offers of a handicap, and partially disrobing as he prepares to play. It describes his technique in approaching a shot, the type of table, who paid, and it acknowledges Lincoln's story-telling as social discourse during the game itself. Parts of this account may be suspect.
NOTE: The 1857 and 1866 Springfield, Illinois, business directories listed the St. Nicholas Hotel (opened in 1855) at Fourth and Jefferson streets as the home of a billiard saloon.
[3] Abraham Lincoln played chess. One of his chess sets is displayed in the Smithsonian.
3a) A contemporary report said Lincoln played a very fair game, but not a first-rate one. While playing chess, Mr. Lincoln seems to be continually thinking of something else. Those who have played him say he plays as if it were a mechanical pastime to occupy his hands while his mind is busy with some other subject. He plays what chess players call a "safe game." Rarely attacking, he is content to let his opponent attack while he concentrates all his energies in the defense — awaiting the opportunity of dashing in at a weak point or the expenditure of his adversary's strength. He was the model of a chess general.
3b) An old friend of Mr. Lincoln once related to me another of his stories which shows not a little of his character. This gentleman was conversing with the President at a time during the War when things looked very dark. On taking leave, he asked the President what he should say to their friends in Kentucky—what cheering news he could give them of him. Mr. Lincoln replied:
"That reminds me of a man who prided himself greatly on his game of chess, having seldom been beaten. He heard of a machine called the "Automaton Chess Player," which was beating everyone who played against it. So he went to try his skill with the machine. He lost the first game, same with the second, and the third games. Then, rising in astonishment from his seat, he walked around the machine and looked at it for a few minutes. Then, stopping and pointing at it, he exclaimed, 'There is a man in there.'"
"Tell my friends," said Mr. Lincoln, "there is a man in here!"
NOTE: The chess automaton, the Turk, aka the Mechanical Turk or Automaton Chess Player, was a fake chess-playing machine constructed in the late 18th century. From 1770 until its destruction by fire in 1854, it was exhibited by various owners as an automaton, though it was eventually revealed to be an elaborate hoax. Constructed and unveiled in 1770 by Wolfgang von Kempelen, the mechanism appeared to be able to play a strong game of chess against a human opponent, as well as perform the "Knight's Tour," a puzzle that requires the player to move a knight to occupy every square of a chessboard exactly once. The Turk was, in fact, a mechanical illusion that allowed a human chess master hiding inside to operate the machine. With a skilled operator, the Turk won most of the games played during its demonstrations around Europe and the Americas for nearly 84 years.
 |
| A copper engraving of the Turk, showing the open cabinets and working parts. |
ADDITIONAL READING: Observations on the automaton chess player. 1819.
