Why do Chicagoans hate ketchup on their hot dogs?

A Chicago Style hot dog must have a poppy seed bun, an all-beef hot dog, yellow mustard, chopped white onions, green sweet pickle relish, a dill pickle spear, fresh tomato slices, or tomato wedges, sport peppers, and a dash of celery salt, or it is not a Chicago dog.

Prejudice for ketchup exists only for hot dogs. Let me explain why putting ketchup on a hot dog in Chicago (and the suburbs) is unacceptable unless you're 10 or younger.

The answer, it turns out, is found in science. It's really quite simple. The fresh tomatoes on the dog replace what ketchup would bring to the party in tomato sweetness. 

References to this prejudice have reached as far as the White House.

President Obama made it official with a proclamation on June 3, 2011, while visiting one of Rudy's Hot Dog stands in Toledo, OH. Obama and the mayor stopped in for a chili dog, but apparently, the subject of ketchup came up. "You shouldn't put ketchup on your hot dog," said President Obama.

CLICK TO WATCH OBAMA AND BOURDAIN [runtime 00:01:30]

"Is ketchup on a hot dog ever acceptable?" Anthony Bourdain asked the leader of the free world in an episode of "Parts Unknown." "No," the President quickly responded. "I mean that ... that's one of those things like, well, let me put it this way, it's not acceptable past the age of 8." "And I agree," Bourdain said, "I think there is a time and a place for ketchup, and I don't think the hot dog is one of them."

Bob Schwartz, a Vice President of Vienna Beef, the leading Chicago hot dog supplier, wrote a book titled "Never Put Ketchup On A Hot Dog" in 2008. He calls ketchup an "affliction."

Mike Royko, Chicago Tribune, Tuesday, November 21, 1995 Article.

"This simple little quiz is directed at those who love hot dogs.

Not any hot dog, but the true, classic Chicago hot dog."

CLICK TO READ THE FULL ARTICLE.

Mike Royko said it better than anyone in a November 21, 1995 column: "No, I won't condemn anyone for putting ketchup on a hot dog. This is the land of the free. And if someone wants to put ketchup on a hot dog and actually eat the awful thing, that is their right. It is also their right to put mayo, chocolate syrup, toenail clippings, or cat hair on a hot dog. Sure, it would be disgusting and perverted, and they would be shaming themselves and their loved ones. But under our system of government, it is their right to be barbarians."

Okay, I've got to ask, which one would you choose;

1. Fresh Tomatoes
2. Heinz Tomato Ketchup — Ingredients: Tomato concentrate from ripe red tomatoes, Distilled Vinegar, High Fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, salt (160mg), spice, onion powder, and natural flavoring. (Serving = 1 Tbsp, 17g)

INDEX TO MY ILLINOIS AND CHICAGO FOOD & RESTAURANT ARTICLES.

Compiled by Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D. 

The History of Green River Soft Drink.

Green River pop (a midwestern term for soda, soda-pop, or soft drink) was introduced to Midwesterners in 1919, just as Congress passed the 18th Amendment establishing Prohibition. Green River soda was first created in 1916 in Davenport, Iowa, by Richard C. Jones, who owned a local confectionary shop. 

Antique Green River Soda Fountain Syrup Bottle. Circa 1915.

In 1919, Jones sold his recipe to the Schoenhofen Edelweiss Brewing Company of Chicago. Before 1920, the brewery produced the popular Edelweiss beer, and Schoenhofen began manufacturing Green River and other soft drinks to survive the Prohibition Era. 

Schoenhofen Brewery - Edelweiss Beer, Chicago.

It was also made by the Sweetwater Brewery in Green River, Wyoming.

When Prohibition officially took effect on January 16, 1920, some breweries turned to produce a nonalcoholic drink called 'Near Beer,' while others were churning out ice cream, and some breweries just closed.

The Schoenhofen Edelweiss Brewing Company was located in the Pilsen neighborhood on 18th Street and Canalport Avenue. Two of the remaining 17 buildings can still be found at that location.

The lime-based pop with a hint of lemon was poured into old beer bottles and sold in the market. The vivid green color and great flavor were an immediate success. It was popular as a soda fountain syrup, trailing only Coca-Cola in popularity throughout the Midwest.

 

Following the closing of the Edelweiss company in 1950, the Green River recipe was passed from one manufacturer to another. This period of Green River history is murky. Sources agree that by the 90s, the beverage was on the ropes—it was only being sold in Seattle (which has a Green River of Green River Killer fame), and it was unclear if anybody else was making more.

Around 1995, the rights and recipe were sold to Clover Club Bottling Company, 356 North Kilbourn Avenue, Chicago, a small independent bottler in Chicago (bottles "Dogs N Suds Root Beer"). Clover Club brought Green River back to life, and then WIT Beverage Company (WBC) took over the brand in 2011 and continued Clover Club's work.

In October of 2021, WIT Beverage Company passed the torch to none other than Sprecher Brewing Company in Glendale, Wisconsin, another Midwestern craft soda icon. As Milwaukee's Original Craft Brewery, Sprecher knows what it means to preserve a legacy and plans to let Green River shine again by re-introducing it to the country that has loved it for over one hundred years.

A Visual History of Green River Bottles.

Green River is frequently marketed as a nostalgia item, and its sales increased in March due to the association of the color green with St. Patrick's Day. 

Chicago celebrates St. Patrick's Day by dyeing the Chicago River green.

While not widely commercially available, it can be purchased at some Chicago area grocery stores and retailers and is served in some Chicagoland restaurants.

With a unique visual appeal, including its bright green color, Green River takes people back to a pleasant time in their life, in the 1950s and '60s, at a time of corner pop fountains and drive-in movies.

According to John Fogerty, the Creedence Clearwater Revival album Green River and Al Jolson's song "Green River" was inspired by the soft drink. 

John Fogerty & Creedence Clearwater Revival Play the song "Green River."

In Zen Studios' (acquired Bally And Williams Pinball Licences in 2018) recreation of the Williams pinball machines "The Party Zone" and "The Champion Pub," Zen Studios' computer pinball game "FX 3" has replaced depictions of beer with Green River. It was a precautionary act of censorship to avoid the repercussions of having the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) rating of "Everyone 10+" changed to a more restrictive rating.

Fans of Green River know that it's not just another soda pop; it's nostalgia in a bottle. 

Compiled by Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D.