Wednesday, December 5, 2018

Marshall Field's Famous Frango Mints, the Myth and Back Story.

"Frango Mints candy was originally a product of the Frederick and Nelson Co. department stores in Seattle, Washington. The chocolates were first known as Franco Mints in the 1920s. When Marshall Field bought those Seattle stores, they also acquired Franco Mints. The name stayed that way until 1939 when Spain's General Francisco 'Franco' became controversial. Field's then changed the name to Frango Mints."
When Macy's purchased Marshall Fields, they began selling the candy in what was supposed to be a copy of the original 1929 Marshall Fields candy gift box. The trouble was that the box identified the candy as "Frango Mints." Was Macy's engaging in historical revisionism?

After some research, it was found that the Franco-to-Frango story needed to be corrected. 

Frederick and Nelson had trademarked its candy as "Frango Mints" on June 1, 1918. It is said that name was a portmanteau for FRederick And Nelson GOodness. Generations of Field's employees had been unknowingly passing down this false tale.

So unless someone comes up with an old box or advertisement for "Franco" Mints, another urban legend has been debunked.

Compiled by Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D.

Originally, "Frango" was the name for a frozen dessert sold at the sophisticated Tea Room at Frederick & Nelson's department store at Sixth Avenue and Pine Street in Seattle, Washington. The first Frango frozen dessert was available in maple and orange flavors.

In 1926, the consistency of the Frango Dessert was described as flaky, requiring a fork, not a spoon, as you would use with ice cream. The Frango name eventually was extended to ice-cream sodas, pies, and milkshakes sold at the store. It wasn't until 1927 that Ray Alden, who ran Frederick's in-store candy kitchen, developed the Frango mint meltaway chocolate.
Alden's secret recipe used chocolate from African and South American cocoa beans, triple-distilled oil of Oregon peppermint, and 40% local butter.
Frederick & Nelson's candy kitchen.
A few months after Marshall Field's agreed to buy out Frederick & Nelson's and take control of the Seattle company in 1929, the Frederick & Nelson candy makers in Seattle were summoned to Chicago to introduce Frango mints to Marshall Field's to help build slumping sales during the Great Depression. Soon, the candy kitchen at Marshall Field's had produced its own Midwestern interpretation of the Frango Chocolate recipe.
Marshall Field's candy kitchen.
Although the Northwest version still uses the original Frederick & Nelson recipe, Marshall Field's recipe has been modified a few times. This and using different ingredients and equipment would account for any difference in taste between the two versions.

One crucial distinction between the two types of Frango chocolates is the packaging. Midwestern Frango chocolates are sold in traditional flat candy boxes, with the chocolates set in candy papers. By contrast, Northwest Frango chocolates are individually wrapped and sold in distinctive hexagon-shaped boxes.
The Midwest version had been produced on the 13th floor of the Marshall Field's flagship State Street store from 1929 until March 1999. However, demand for the chocolates overwhelmed the in-house facility; consequently, then corporate owner Dayton-Hudson Corp. handed over the production contract for Frangos to Gertrude Hawk Chocolates in Dunmore, Pennsylvania and closed the Field's candy kitchen, letting go virtually all of the candy kitchen's employees. This infuriated many Chicagoans and enraged Chicago Mayor Richard M. Daley, who sought to have the iconic chocolates made by a local Chicago company.

Garrett Brands (Chicago's Garrett Popcorn and Frango brands) has been producing Macy's (Marshall Field's) Frango mints since 2017.


  1. Don Greenberg, Suppose you and Beth got the two boxes we sent on Sunday. I saw the option of wrapped mints and (not knowing any better) "that can't be right" and moved on. I had no idea, until you sent this history, that wrapped mints were bonafide. Too many options, so I had to call in the expert on Chocolates in this house. Bob made the selections.
    Thanks Dr. Gale for enlightening us.

  2. While the history is very interesting, it doesn't change the fact that those were the best chocolate mints ever. My mother used to bring them home when we were kids and were lucky if they lasted 24 hours. She even put them out in a candy dish when entertaining a sign of her good taste, I guess.

  3. I found an old Frango Mints paper container in my mother's estate... storing her pin cushion. It's clearly very old and thinking older than most of the images I'm finding online since all of the product info is prunted on the front of the container. Anyone know of someone who could help me date it?

    1. Send photos, front, sides, bottom and of the inside to:

    2. If Anonymous (Oct 2022) sent photos, can you publish them? Did you discover anything? My father grew up in Chicago and likely ate some of the first Frangos sold there. Long history! Thanks for the info.

  4. Hi Neil, As of today, is Garrett Popcorn still producing Frango Mints for Macy's? Do you know which recipe they are using? Chicago or Seattle? They sell a very small selection of Frango Mints on their website, but the logo and packaging is completely different from Macy's. Which leads me to believe they are using the Seattle recipe (original) for their website products and the Chicago recipe for Macy's versions. But I might be wrong. My family and I are going to be doing some comparison taste testing and I'm trying to do some research. Thank you so much for any help or insight you can provide!

    1. Try emailing Garrett Popcorn at:

    2. Thank you so much, Neil. I'll give that a try.

    3. I was searching for the Northwest version and I see that, as of today, both the Chicago (boxed) and Seattle (individually wrapped) versions are available on Garret’s website.

  5. My grandmother (lived in Seattle from 5yrs old -which was from 1914 until her death) used to buy those from the original chocolate frango mints made in the Fredrick and Nelson’s downtown Seattle store where it all started. My mother (born in Seattle 1941) grew up in Magnolia and again, those were the best chocolates ever! It’s truly unfortunate they now are putting bioengineered ingredients and soy - which was never the recipe! Truly disappointed! My Grandmother “Molly” Mary Fellows would truly be disappointed if she had the new” Frangos - as I am as well; and I left Seattle area back in 2000. Sadly, this is the first try of the new smaller bit size not good frango mints in a flat box, very disappointing!

  6. I totally agree as a past employee of F&N in Seattle. They definitely have a different taste. Wont be purchasing them again.


The Digital Research Library of Illinois History Journal™ is RATED PG-13. Please comment accordingly. Advertisements, spammers and scammers will be removed.