The Real Bristol Renaissance Faire Garlic Butter Mushroom recipe; portioned for at-home cooks.

A vendor, I don't remember his name, so I'll call him Chef Mike, sold the most delicious garlic butter mushrooms at the Bristol Renaissance Faire in Bristol, Wisconsin (near Kenosha). Be sure to buy a quart on your way out.

I'm still trying to remember the year I became interested in Garlic Butter Mushrooms. It has nothing to do with watching her stir the pot for a minute!

From memory: Chef Mike started making and selling his garlic butter mushrooms for the King Richard's Faire in the late 1970s, today's Bristol Renaissance Faire. After chatting with Chef Mike every year and asking for the recipe, he finally told me in the mid-1990s, "My kid didn't want my business," so he'll give me his recipe, "You are persistent. You've come here every year for a long time,  so I know you'll enjoy the mushrooms." I wrote down what he told me.

A different gentleman was stringing the pot in the same spot the following year. I bought some mushrooms — Lo and behold — they were exactly the same! 

On my way out of the Faire, I always purchased a quart or two (one to give as a gift). I asked him about Chef Mike, "He sold me his business and retired to Arizona." 

Chef Mike reviewed the recipe I wrote down and said, "You got it."

I recalculated, checked, and then double-checked Chef Mike's recipe from his commercial recipe, which I wrote down and portioned for at-home cooks. You may do the math to report the recipe to meet your needs.

---

Chef Mike's Garlic Butter Mushroom Recipe

YOU WILL BE 100% SATISFIED REMEMBERING THE TASTE AT THE FAIRE IF YOU FOLLOW THIS RECIPE EXACTLY THE FIRST TIME YOU MAKE IT.

Do you remember the mushrooms at the Renaissance Faire being too salty? ME NEITHER.

INGREDIENTS

2 pounds whole mushrooms; Button, Cremini, or both, stems trimmed

Mushroom Brush

2 cups white onion, roughly chopped

3 tablespoons unsalted butter

2 LEVEL tablespoons salt (see: Note From The Chef, below)

1/2 teaspoon cracked black pepper, not too coarse

10 cloves of Garlic, Very Thinly Sliced

1/2 cup of a quality dry White Wine (Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon

      Blanc, Chablis, dry Reisling, or your favorite white wine)

HEED WHAT CHEF MIKE SAID TO ME

"I know that 2 tablespoons of salt seems like a lot. If you’re like me, you tend to routinely reduce the salt or totally leave the salt out of some recipes. After making several thousand pounds of mushrooms, I know one thing. If you don’t salt the mushrooms adequately while they are cooking, you’ll end up adding twice as much salt later to get the same flavor."   

Chef Mike   

PLEASE DO NOT CUT THE SALT THE FIRST TIME YOU MAKE THIS

SEE READERS COMMENTS BELOW.

DIRECTIONS

Lightly clean the mushrooms with a mushroom brush or with a paper towel. Then, place the mushrooms in a bowl and add enough water to cover them. (Since mushrooms float, put a plate over them to weigh them down and keep them underwater.)

Add the mushrooms to a large pot.

You'll have enough to share if you multiply the recipe by two or three.

Cover with water. Add a plate over the top that will fit INSIDE THE POT to ensure the mushrooms get an 8-hour or overnight soaking.

Next, heat a large skillet on medium heat. Add the butter and let it melt. Toss in the onions, garlic, and cracked black pepper. Give it a nice toss. Let this cook on medium heat, stirring along the way, until the onions soften, about 5-7 minutes.

  DO NOT BROWN OR CARAMELIZE THE ONIONS; IT WILL TOTALLY RUIN THIS RECIPE.  

Remove the plate from the mushrooms, and add the onion mixture to the pot. Add in the salt and white wine. Stir. Cover the pot and bring the mixture to a simmer. Simmer for about 8 hours. Yes, 8 hours. 

At about 6 hours in, remove the cover and bring the heat up to medium. Then cook for the remaining 2 hours.

The broth will reduce a bit, which is normal. You'll have plenty of broth, so do not water it down.

Here, this one's for you.

CHEF MIKE TOLD ME, "From my years of experience running mushroom stands  at 20-something Renaissance Fairs around the country, the amount of salt has not been an issue."

A partial list of U.S. Renaissance Faires That Sold Chef Mike's Garlic Butter Mushrooms.

All Faire, Lacey, WA

Bristol Renaissance Faire, Kenosha, WI

Canterbury Renaissance Faire, Oregon

Carolina Renaissance Festival, Concord, NC

Carolina Renaissance Festival, Huntersville, NC

Central Coast Renaissance Festival, San Luis Obispo, CA

Colorado Renaissance Festival,  Larkspur,  CO

Glastonbury Renaissance Faire, Toledo, OR

Koroneburg Renaissance Festival, Corona, CA

Koroneburg Renaissance Festival, Los Angeles, A.

Maine Renaissance Faire,Acton,ME

Mid-Michigan Renaissance Festival, Vassar, MI

Midsummer Renaissance Faire, Ansonia, CT

Newbourne Village Renaissance Faire, Chippewa Falls, WI

North Dakota Renaissance Faire,  Fargo,  ND

Pittsburgh Renaissance Festival, West Newton, PA

Pride Renaissance Tour, Lansing, MI

Renaissance Fair, Orlando, FL

Renaissance Festival, Austin, TX

Santa Fe Renaissance Fair, Santa Fe,  NM

Sterling Renaissance Festival, Sterling, NY

Upstate Renaissance Faire, Greer, SC

Vermont Renaissance Faire, Stowe, VT

Washington Midsummer Renaissance Faire, Snohomish, WA

West Virginia Renaissance Festival, Lewisburg, WV

Shared by Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D.

Please come back to tell us how your mushrooms turned out.