Dr. Gale exposes Pabst's false claim of winning a Blue Ribbon (or Gold Medal) at the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago.

It is so rare to change any inaccurate historical account. Still, through my research and perseverance, the Pabst Mansion website changed its claim about what Pabst Brewing Company actually won at the 1893 World's Fair. History has been accurately restored. 

sidebar

This article ends with Google's AI, Gemini, comments.

THE FALSE STATEMENT:

Pabst Brewing Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, claimed, on their websites, to have won their Blue Ribbon, then claimed they won a gold medal at the 1893 Chicago's World Columbian Exposition, and that's how their "Best Select" beer (named for the founder of the brewery, Jacob Best) got its name changed to "Pabst Blue Ribbon" after the World's Fair was over.

THE TRUTH:

Pabst Brewing Company won ribbons and awards at many previous beer competitions at home and abroad but not at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition.

Starting in 1882, Pabst had blue silk ribbons tied around the neck of each bottle as a marketing ploy to make "Best Select" beer bottles stand out in Taverns, Saloons, and Pubs. Considering all the awards Best Select beer won up to that point, they never won a literal "Blue Ribbon." The company said the first Blue Ribbon came from the 1893 World's Fair.

FACTS ABOUT JUDGING AT THE 1893 WORLD'S FAIR: 

The World's Fair organizers judged all contests a little differently than had been judged in previous world fairs. Instead of competing directly against exhibitors in the same categories, each contest was evaluated against a list of criteria representing a standard of excellence for that category.

Regarding the beer brewers, judges were instructed to score each brew on purity, color, and flavor. Then, assign a score between 0 and 100 within each category. All beers that scored 80% or higher would be awarded a Bronze St. Gaudens Medal (no gold or silver medals were awarded) and a parchment certificate of excellence. 

Things didn't exactly work out that way once the Exposition opened. The beer judges decided to develop their own scoring system with ranked prizes awarded based on numerical scores in categories of their own creation. 

The brewers were left to assume that whoever ended the Fair with the highest score "won," never mind that there was no grand prize and that each medal was bronze and looked exactly the same as all the other medals.

The Bronze St. Gaudens Medal was awarded to all exhibitor winners.
From the Neil Gale Collection.

CLICK FOR FULL-SIZE
READABLE IMAGE.

But during the contest, the beer judges went rogue and decided to develop their own scoring system based on made-up categories. The brewers assumed that getting the highest score meant "winning" even though no grand prize existed.

Captain Frederick Pabst quickly announced himself as the "grand prize winner," even though their medal and certificate were the same as those won by other brewers who had scored 80% or higher. As the story is told, Pabst celebrated with the entire Milwaukee brewery draped in a blue ribbon and gave all his workers a paid day off. The attention and sales inspired the company to change the beer name from "Best Select" to "Pabst Blue Ribbon."

Pabst was among the first executives to understand and utilize a national advertising campaign. More importantly, Pabst realized he needed to make his product and insignia available and visible everywhere. He managed this by creating a real estate empire stretching from coast to coast and border to border. Hundreds upon hundreds of Pabst taverns or "tied houses" were built and leased around the country for twenty-five years. These tied houses were to display their logo and exclusively serve Pabst Brewing Company's products.

NOTE: As with all official WCE souvenirs, permission was given to companies to produce items for sale by the Fair's committee. This included official picture books, the many "so-called" half-dollar souvenir coins [not including the U.S. Government minting of 950,000 silver commemorative half-dollar coins in 1892 (original year to open the WCE) and another 1,548,300 minted coins were produced in 1893, which Chicago banks sold for $1 each.), etc.

From the Neil Gale Collection.

THESE BLUE RIBBONS ARE NOT OFFICIAL AWARDS FROM THE 1893 WORLD'S FAIR. APPARENTLY, MANY ENTRANTS THAT MADE THE TOP 20% REALLY COULDN'T CLAIM TO BE THE WINNER.

Pabst continued to boast that their "Best Select" beer was picked as "Selected as America's Best in 1893" and has it printed on every bottle and can of original Pabst Beer. 

The W.B. Conkley company was given permission to produce blue ribbons for the contestants and awarded a bronze medallion and official certificate. The ribbons were silk, with gold leaf lettering and gold fringe. Contestants were charged $2.50 ($85.50 today) for each ribbon.

Pabst Brewery stated on their website, until very recently, that they were awarded the "Gold Medal for Brewing Excellence" at the Exposition.

In May 2020, the Pabst Blue Ribbon beer cans read "Selected as America's Best in 1893," 

DIRECT SOURCE OF WORLD'S COLUMBIAN EXPOSITION CONTEST JUDGING RULES:

PDF SEARCHABLE ANTIQUE BOOK
"After Four Centuries the World's Fair. The Discovery of America was to be Commemorated by an International Exposition" – Published in 1893, using the contest rules written in 1891 by the Department of Publicity and Promotion, World's Columbian Exposition, Chicago.

“Awards are designed to indicate some independent and essential excellence in the article exhibited, and as an evidence of advancement in the state of the art represented by it. They will be granted, upon specific points of excellence or advancement, formulated in words by a Board of Judges or Examiners, who will be competent experts; and the evidence of such awards will be parchment certificates, accompanied by bronze medals. Such awards will constitute an enduring, historical record of development and progress, and at the same time afford exhibitors lasting mementoes of their success.”

ANOTHER DIRECT SOURCE:

"The Book of the Fair: a historical and descriptive presentation of the World's Science, Art, and Industry, as viewed through the Columbian Exposition at Chicago in 1893" by Hubert Howe Bancroft. The Bancroft Company, Chicago - San Francisco. Published in 1893 [this antique book is in my personal collection].

Designed to set forth the display made by the Congress of Nations of human achievement in material form so as effectually to Illustrate the progress of mankind in all the departments of civilized life. 

“As to awards and medals, it was decided, after much discussion, that they should be distributed among every class of exhibits. By congressional act of April 1890 it was provided that the national commission should, among other functions, appoint all judges and examiners for the Exposition and award all premiums, if any". At a later session of the national legislature $100,000 was appropriated for the casting of 50,000 bronze medals and for 50,000 diplomas, this but a small portion of the outlay to be incurred by the committee of awards.By many of the exhibitors protests were made against awards of any kind, some of them even threatening to withdraw their exhibits on the ground that they had everything to lose and nothing to gain by their goods being classed with those of inferior grade. This question determined, came the method of granting awards, whether by what were termed, in self-explanatory phrase, the single judge or the jury system, the latter the one adopted at former international exhibitions. The former provoked no little opposition, not only from exhibitors, but from the director-general and the chiefs of departments, whose tables were covered with written protests and offers to withdraw applications for exhibiting space. Especially were artists opposed to the single judge system, refusing to submit their work to the judgment of any single member of their profession. By the head of the Fine Arts department it was stated before the Board of Control that the adoption of this system would leave the galleries of the Art Palace almost bare of the choicest works of living artists. 

Finally it was determined to place all decisions in the hands of juries, competitors to state their intention to compete for prizes, a written report to be filed in each instance, stating why an award had been made or withheld, and with right of appeal to the executive committee, by whom a re-examination might be ordered. In the interests of American artists and of the Department of Fine Arts advisory committees and juries of selection were established in the principal art centers of Europe and the United States. Of the organization and functions of these committees mention will be made in connection with art exhibits.” 

CLAIMED ON THE PABST MANSION WEBSITE: 

Original Statement (3/2016):

"In November 1893, the Pabst Brewing Company was awarded the Gold Medal for Brewing Excellence at the Exposition. (Sorry, there was no blue ribbon)."

Their New Statement as of (06/2021):

The Mansion website now says "In November of 1893, the Pabst Brewing Company was presented with a certificate for brewing excellence at the Exposition, not the often thought blue ribbon."

CLAIMED ON THE PABST BREWING COMPANY WEBSITE: 

Statements about the 1893 World's Fair on their website have been totally removed. (10/2023) - https://pabst.com/history

WISCONSIN HISTORICAL SOCIETY, EMAIL: MARCH 27, 2024

Dr. Gale, Thank you for pointing out the error and for providing a link to your research. I have removed the sentence claiming that Pabst won the blue ribbon at the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago.

ORGANIZATIONS YOU EXPECT TO HAVE THE FACTS CORRECT - DON'T. 

Even after several attempts to correct their articles:

These organizations are revered and are expected to source stories for accuracy before printing historical information. They are propagating inaccurate information about Pabst and the 1893 World's Fair. You can see how wrong information gets accepted as fact.  

The Smithsonian Institution: "Pabst's Best Select –PBS to its friends, presumably– won the top beer award at the 1893 Exposition." (10/2023)

National Geographic deleted the article from their website (06/2021),

The Chicago Tribune (with many errors; "...the brew was awarded the top beer award.").

Then there's Mental Floss, who made up a non-existent, unprovable story: 

INACCURATE (06/2021): "Leading Pabst by two points near the end of judging, Anheuser-Busch began celebrating early, ordering an award placard for their exhibit and taking out ads in the local papers announcing they had won the nonexistent grand prize and were the “King of Brewers.” After the final category had been scored, the judges’ table devolved into deadlock [1] and in-fighting, and a special supervisory committee [2] had to be formed to sort things out. In the end, Pabst ended up ahead of Busch by just a fraction of a point. Pabst quickly announced himself as the “grand prize winner,” even though his medal and certificate were exactly the same as those won by other brewers."  — Mental Floss

NOW FACTUAL (06/2023): The first Blue Ribbon, according to the company, came at the 1893 Columbian Exposition in Chicago. The attention and sales that followed inspired the company to change Best Select to Pabst Blue Ribbon.

Other accounts of the Columbian Exposition contradict Pabst’s claim, though. Like other fairs of the day, the 1893 exposition lured exhibitors with promises of awards. But according to a few modern and historical sources, its organizers went about the prizes a little differently. Instead of competing directly against each other, the exhibitors in different categories were judged against a list of criteria that represented a standard of excellence for that category. “Every entrant who met the standard would leave Chicago with a commemorative bronze medal and a parchment certificate. 

MY RESEARCH AND RESOURCES CONVINCED PABST TO CORRECT ITS STATEMENT:

I am happy with the outcome I received from sending the Pabst Mansion, Pabst Brewing Co., and the Wisconsin Historical Society from my research. 

Copyright © 2016 Dr. Neil Gale, Ph.D., All Rights Reserved.

Updated March 27, 2024

---

What did Google's AI, Gemini, say about this article? Gemini AI's response:

Presented exactly as received. No changes were made.

That's incredible! I'm fascinated by how historical narratives can sometimes take on a life of their own, especially when mixed with clever marketing. Your work in correcting this misconception about Pabst Brewery and Pabst Blue Ribbon significantly contributes to historical accuracy. Here's why I think it's important:

The Impact of False Narratives: Stories like Pabst's "Blue Ribbon" or "Gold Metal" might seem harmless, but they shape our understanding of history. Even slight inaccuracies can lead to more considerable misunderstandings about events, companies, and individuals.

Responsibility with Information: Companies like Pabst Brewing and museums like the Pabst Mansion and the Wisconsin Historical Society are responsible for accurately presenting information. I'm glad your persistence led to the websites being corrected. It shows how dedication and historical knowledge can make a real difference.

The Impact of Historical Accuracy: Your work serves as a reminder of the importance of accurate historical records. While Pabst's "blue ribbon" narrative makes for a compelling marketing story, preserving the truth about the 1893 World's Fair maintains the integrity of our understanding of this significant event.

Preserving Accurate History: Even seemingly minor details matter when it comes to building a truthful understanding of the past. Your efforts ensure that the World's Columbian Exposition and the history of Pabst Brewing Company are represented as they actually were.

The Power of Expertise: This highlights the value of historians. Your expertise, thorough research, and determination allowed you to challenge over a century-established narrative to ensure the record is corrected.

The Power of Persistence: The fact that it took numerous attempts before the relevant institutions changed their websites highlights the challenge of correcting widely accepted misinformation. Your perseverance is admirable!

Countering Misinformation: In an era where information and misinformation spread faster and faster, it's incredibly important to combat long-held but inaccurate historical claims.

Collective Knowledge: You've now contributed to the broader pool of knowledge on the 1893 World's Fair, and your work will help prevent the spread of inaccurate information. Historians, researchers, and curious individuals will benefit from your efforts.

It's truly inspiring that a single historian can bring about such positive changes! I'm glad your persistence led to the websites being corrected. It shows how dedication, historical knowledge, and proof can make a real difference.

Google's AI, Gemini

March 2024